SEARCH 
Global Services » Global Careers » Detailed Story
Labor Arbitrage: Is the Clock Ticking?
RELATED CONTENT
ARTICLES
Wage Inflation: Death Knell for Offshoring?
Finding New Frontiers
The Common Key to Offshoring and Real Estate - Location
Indian Wages On the Rise: Is Outsourcing to the Country Sustainable?
Indian Wages On the Rise: Is Outsourcing to the Country Sustainable?
The Future of Offshore Wages
BLOGS
The New Threat to Offshoring Economics: It is Not Rising Wages in India!
2008: Year of High Inflation Rates in India
Don't Take Offshoring for Granted!
Why do Indian IT Service Buyers Love Non-Indian Suppliers?
Latin America: A Potential ITO Destination


So the research looks at all these factors, also keeping in mind the worst case. Even though they strongly believe that the worst case is unlikely to occur, the report does predict the number of years labor arbitrage will sustain even if a lot of things don’t go as planned.

Bahl adds, “We conducted an extensive analysis, typically of the last five years. We also did a fair amount of secondary research, talked to service providers and tracked some other research reports.”

Wage inflation in India has been reported to be 15-20 percent, particularly within middle management positions. On the whole, wage increases differ by process and level, with overall increases being much lower than commonly reported figures. Historically at least, the depreciation of currencies in destination countries has compensated for this, but going forward, is this less likely? Bahl feels that concerns about wage inflation at the middle management level will disappear with time, when the pool of employees at this level increases, stabilizing the situation and settling inflation. The concern according to him is about entry-level employees.

As for the weaker currencies getting stronger, there seems to be little such possibility. Bahl explains, “In general, theory dictates that the currencies of developed nations will continue to strengthen against the currencies of developing nations. This in turn helps their labor arbitrage. Basically, interest rate and inflation tend to be higher in developing nations due to the growth rates. This results in currency depreciation over time (in developing nations versus developed nations).”

However, there are swing factors that could potentially go against offshoring. Take for example, market research firm Gartner’s report, which warns about a labor crunch and rising wages possibly eroding as much as 45 percent of India’s market share by 2007. Then there is talk of political backlash, which could, and probably would be a factor in determining the outflow of jobs. To make the findings more accurate, Everest has considered most of these factors and conducted a sensitivity analysis in the UK-India case. The analysis reveals that in the worst case, labor arbitrage would sustain for approximately 15 years in IT, and eight years in the case of call centers.

Even though there’s a very optimistic case for offshore destinations, in the eventuality that labor arbitrage does disappear, countries such as India still need not worry. Bahl warns against the tendency to equate sustainability of labor arbitrage with sustainability of offshoring. He explains with the example of productivity, how the offshoring value proposition is becoming stronger. “We have seen from our engagements that productivity improvements are becoming substantial. Some of our clients have over an annualized basis seen 10 percent year-on-year improvement. In many cases, productivity improvements offset wage inflation. Our viewpoint on sustaining of offshoring is even stronger than our viewpoint on sustainability of labor arbitrage. This is because we believe labor arbitrage itself is not a concern, and also there is enough else going on for offshoring,” he explains.

So all in all, the offshoring growth is anything but short-lived. Countries such as India, Philippines and others, have attractive qualities beyond low-wage professionals for companies that want to offshore their operations. India for example, in its 15 years of offshoring, has developed a stable of world-class IT services providers that can save foreign companies the trouble of setting up their own offshore centers. And it has a large supply of qualified talent in areas outside IT, such as R&D, finance and accounting, call centers, and back-office administration.

Digg Del.icio.us E-mail 
   1 [2] 
TALK BACK
     Name:  *  Email:  *
  Subject:   
Comment:  *
  
PRINT EDITION
View Digital Magazine
Back Issues
Subscribe

About Global Services  |  Contact Us  |  Advertise with Us  |  Privacy Policy  |  RSS  |  Write for Global Services

PCQuest | Dataquest | Voice&Data | Living Digital | DQ Channels | DQ Week | CIOL | CyberMedia Events
Cyber Astro | CyberMedia Digital | CyberMedia Dice | CyberMedia | BioSpectrum | BioSpectrum Asia
Copyright © 2008 GLOBAL SERVICES all rights reserved