Chinas fast-growing and fast-evolving markets are challenging
foreign and local companies to keep up with shifting demands for
their products and services. As a consequence, we are starting to see
outsourcing used in ways that go far beyond cost and
quality—suggesting how outsourcing can strategically assist expansion
into new markets, introduction of new products, and development of
new business models.
The thesis that emerges—where outsourcing permits one to conserve
resources, maintain flexibility, and define scale in concert with
demand—is intuitive, powerful, and likely to be useful to companies
outside of China.
New Markets
Many companies are moving into China to capitalize on growing
domestic demand for industrial and consumer products. Most of these
firms have little or no experience in China and are thus vulnerable
to various mistakes. Instinctively, these firms have tried to insure
against problems by simplifying their operations during the initial
entry phase. This minimalist approach to survival has prompted
increased use of outsourcing for both essential and non-essential
capabilities.
Take the example of Dan, who runs the operations of a medium-sized
American company in China. When his CEO asked him to take charge of
globalizing the firms production, Dan knew little about China. After
his team informed him of the advantages likely to be gained from
setting up several plants in China, Dan was persuaded. He still
needed to decide how much of his current operation to bring to China.
Should he bring the entire model or just a portion? He had heard
friends say, Keep it simple at first—you can always add more
functions later.
As Dan reviewed the business case, he noticed that 35% of the entry
costs were attributed to support functions like finance and human
resources, which were populated by expatriates. More critically, he
became concerned about the processes these expats would bring with
them. He already knew that there was too much bureaucracy at the U.S.
plants, and bringing even a portion of that overseas would kill any
hope of profit from a new operation.
After careful review, he made a decision to bring slightly more than
half of the typical operational model. Of the remaining portion, he
arranged to outsource the back-office functions to a provider in
China—at least temporarily until the operation grew in sophistication
and need. The final portion of the model was simply discarded—a
radical move that he had long hoped to make but never had the freedom
to accomplish until now.
During his first year in China, Dan learned that flexibility meant
everything. Although the sales team had built decent momentum, demand
was anything but smooth. By avoiding fixed investment in the support
functions, Dan found that he was able to invest in more flexible
production equipment in the main plant. His strategy of using
outsourcing to allow him to bend and flex with the market paid off.
He eventually renewed his services contract for another three years.
While hypermarket applications cannot tell us exactly how the same
techniques would work if applied to more conventional markets, they
do suggest what benefits might accrue under somewhat similar
conditions. In Dans case, market variables could not be predicted
with any accuracy because of the emerging nature of the situation,
and flexibility was a key to profitability. By concentrating his
resources on operations rather than support functions, Dan was able
to multiply his chances for success. By expanding into new markets,
even outside China, managers would be well advised to consider more
aggressive use of lean expansion, made possible by outsourcing of
selected requirements.
New Products
The use of outsourcing in China is not limited to
foreign companies. Domestic companies are experimenting with the use
of outside services as a way to minimize risk of product launch and
evolution. Some of these decisions are a matter of necessity, while
others are a matter of choice. With consumer preferences fomenting
and incomes rising, new product needs are emerging daily. Most firms
still try to manage design, production, distribution, and support
internally, but more are now realizing that attacking the opening is
more critical than controlling all aspects of the business.
Ba Lin, a marketing manager with a Beijing firm, faced just such a
challenge. The management committee of her company had recently
approved a new line of small appliances geared toward new property
buyers. With spring fast approaching, Ba Lin knew that she had to act
fast to get product into the channel. As a result, she could not
follow the conventional approach of using in-house resources for all
aspects of the effort. In particular, she knew that the new products
were likely to be complicated for consumers to use and that calls to
the help center would increase.
To speed the process, she carved out the marketing and
customer-support components—including direct-mail campaign management
and help-desk support—into a set of needs that outside companies
could now provide. After vetting numerous offers, she settled on one
firm for marketing communications creation and program management and
another for operating the help-desk and customer-service aspects. Her
companys existing capabilities in both areas were already stretched
to the limit. Additionally, this new line would require different
experience, making outsourcing the only option.
Six months after the launch, the line was still not meeting targets,
and Ba Lin recommended that her company substantially reduce its
commitment to going forward. As she pulled back, she realized that
the decision to outsource support functions had been wise. She simply
exercised her contractual right to terminate the services with two
months notice—which limited her exposure to further losses in the
new line and enabled her to consider an alternative line for the fall
season. Being able to switch out of one approach and into another
with little friction meant that she would still have a chance to
optimize her product portfolio for the year.
New Business Models
The chaotic conditions of Chinas markets are
leading firms to create new approaches to doing business—new business
models, to some extent. Some models are the outcome of sharp demand
colliding with scarce supply, and others simply are the result of
piecing together a process to satisfy an attractive, even if
temporary, opportunity.
Operating in Shanghai, John faced the unusual difficulty of replacing
something in his business model that he had taken for granted in the
U.S.—the ability to use a credit card to pay for his products. Still
emerging, Chinas credit-card system is not yet a mainstream payment
method. Johns consumer-electronics business, although operating in
just one city at this point, was based on internet orders and quick
delivery. Without a payment method with immediate clearance, his
entire business plan would be undermined.
Recognizing that the delivery companies might be able to help, John
arranged for a company to pick up checks from customers one day prior
to the delivery of their orders. The extra time was an inconvenience
for the customers, but tolerable given the excellent pricing that
John was able to provide. The service provided by the delivery
company seemed to work fairly well. John concluded that the early
trial would suffice until China regulators approved a more permanent
approach.
Outsourcing—or the borrowing of capabilities for a particular
purpose—is becoming more sophisticated in application and can clearly
play an important role in growth strategies in emerging markets and
elsewhere. From the Petri dish that is China, it is possible to see
how the sourcing of capabilities can supplement or complement ones
own skills in fast-changing situations where flexibility and
adaptation are paramount.
Tom Manning, a former partner of Bain & Company, is now a board director and investor, who frequently comments on globalization, technology, and China. He can be reached at Tom.Manning@ChinaBoardDirectors.com.