Guilbault is an analyst at Technology
Business Research
Successful IT
and BPO firms, along with companies aiming to establish captive
shops, are beginning to seriously consider South Africa as a location
from which to deliver services, and to a lesser extent as a potential
market. The South African government has become aware of the potentially
lucrative BPO industry, but, to date has not manifested its understanding
through actions to support its growth. Though it remains to be seen
whether businesses and governments in the nation will be able to
put together a compelling offering for firms in the BPO industry,
South Africa does have a number of advantages that make it an attractive
prospect.
| South Africa currently has some 550 call centers, of which about 175 are pocket call centers with
fewer than 20 seats each |
The South African
BPO industry is currently valued at approximately $1.5 billion and
is growing at 14 per cent annually. The best case growth forecasts
from the South African Department of Trade and Industry indicate
that the industry has the potential to grow at a compound annual
rate exceeding 20 per cent for each year between 2005 and 2015,
boosted by pending initiatives to support the BPO industry going
forward. Although this forecast seems overly optimistic at first,
English-speaking businesses in the US and the UK, and Dutch-speaking
businesses in the Netherlands are key parties already showing interest
in expansion to the region.
| South Africas
Largest Call-Center Operators |
| Ask Africa |
Callrica |
| Absolutvalu |
Denwa Direct |
| Absolutvalu |
Denwa Direct |
| Blake Holdings |
FastVoice Consulting |
| 3iSolutions |
Prime Consulting |
| Comparex |
Solus Telemarketing |
| Call Center Nucleus |
Syntell Business Solutions |
| Source: SACCCOM |
South Africas BPO industry
has traditionally been concentrated in call-center operations. South
Africa is currently home to approximately 550 call centers, of which
approximately 175 are so-called pocket call centers having fewer
than 20 seats each. The majority of South Africas call centers
serve the domestic market although at this time, at least 20 facilities
serve international clients. The key BPO providers serving international
clients from South Africa include Sykes and Merchants, serving US
firms, and Mindpearl, serving European clients. Among the large
multinational companies that have set up captive shops in South
Africa are Computer Sciences Corporation, Affiliated Computer Services
and Lufthansa Airlines.
As a potential offshoring
destination for BPO activities, the country has a number of advantages.
One quality that has been differentiating is South
Africas sizable English and Dutch-speaking population.
| Comparative
Labor Rate by Country |
| Country |
Labor Rate ($ per hour) |
| Brazil |
$3.00 to $4.00 |
| Canada |
$5.00 to $7.00 |
| India |
$1.00 to $2.00 |
| Jamaica |
$2.50 to $3.00 |
| Mexico |
$3.50 to $5.00 |
| New Zealand |
$5.00 to $7.00 |
| Ireland |
$5.50 to $6.50 |
| Portugal |
$7.00 to $10.00 |
| Puerto Rico |
$5.15 to $8.00 |
| South Africa |
$3.50 to $5.00 |
| Spain |
$7.00 to $10.00 |
| United States |
$7.50 to $14.00 |
| Source: Media Sources and
Trade Industry of South Africa |
South African firms boast that
accents of their workers are neutral enough to fool English speakers
in all the Anglo-phone countries. South Africa also resides in the
same time zone as parts of Europe (GMT+1, GMT+2) making business
communications easier. Though relatively few in number, South African
BPO providers have considerable experience delivering BPO services,
and the nation is experiencing economic and political stability.
Moreover, because South Africa is not currently experiencing an
economic boom, wages and real estate values are lower than those
in more mature markets including India, Canada and even the Philippines.
On the other hand, South Africa
also has several disadvantages that must be considered to assess
the long-term viability of BPO businesses in the country. Among
the technological disadvantages are its limited telecommunications
infrastructure and its constrained international bandwidth. TBR
estimates that at the end of 2004, fewer than 14 per cent of South
African households had Internet access. The problem is exacerbated
by an oligopoly of ISPs in the nation, with the top five having
85 per cent market share.
The ISPs provide limited international
bandwidth as well. TBR estimates that South Africas total international
bandwidth is less than 2 Gbps, although it is growing rapidly. This
bandwidth is rapidly consumed by multimedia content and the rapid
growth of Virtual Private Networks using the public Internet. In
terms of government support and incentives aimed to support the
BPO industry, South Africa comes up short compared to India. The
quality of its educational system also lags behind that of India,
and the size of the labor pool is much smaller (current BPO call
centers employ approximately 35,000 people).
Some International Companies
in South Africa
| Company Name and Country of
Origin |
Current or Projected Investment |
| MindPearl (Swiss) |
200-seat call center located in Cape Town |
| Computer Sciences Corporation (American) |
More than 500 employees in 3 BPO centers: Cape Town,
Johannesburg, Richards Bay |
| Global Telesales – Lufthansa subsidiary (German) |
Operates a $900,000 call center in Cape Town with 120
seats |
| The Qualifyer Group (Dutch) |
Operates a call center in Western Cape with more than
400 seats |
| Sykes (American) |
Operates a 300-seat call center in Johannesburg |
| Digitalmall.com (British) |
Operates call centers with more than 500 seats across
the country |
| Dialogue UK (British) |
Invested $3.0 million in Cape Town call center |
| Dimension Data (British) |
Operates call centers in Johannesburg and Cape Town |
| Active Content Solutions (British) |
Operates 60-seat call center in Cape Town |
| Electronic Data Systems (American) |
Operates BPO centers in Johannesburg and Cape Town; More
than 1,000 employees |
| The Budget Group (British) |
$15 million to establish a call center in Cape Town |
| Source: Company sites and South African
Department of Trade and Industry |
In the end, an
analysis of the overall environment for the IT industry in South
Africa reveals that the country is well-positioned in terms of its
skill base, infrastructure, economy and international profile to
grow as a niche provider in software development. Conversely, social
barriers, low literacy levels, limited government funding and involvement,
and insufficient skills development demand that if the country is
to realize its potential, it will need to develop a national IT
vision and culture that promotes IT development and skills to go
forward.